In other words, although the religious order on human cloning can be an. Courtney campbell, director of the program for ethics, science and the environment at oregon state university, says, some traditions and leading. Bioethicists, policy makers, and the media have been quick to identify the key ethical. They see human cloning as a means of weakening religious beliefs, changing gods creation, violating human dignity, disturbing family life, and bringing heritage and lineage regulations into disarray. And scientist biographies, and views on both sides of the cloning debate. Terms in this set 28 a common ethical objection to human reproductive cloning is which of the following. Nov 24, 2001 the need to obtain a supply of human eggs leads to one of the most sensitive ethical issues cloning research. Apr 21, 2010 what are some of the ethical issues of cloning. According the ethical and religious directives for catholic health care services, direct sterilization of either men or women is only permitted when their direct effect is the cure or alleviation of a present and serious pathology and a simpler treatment is not available. He proposes a worldwide ban on human cloning, saying that it should carry a penalty on a par with rape, child abuse and murder. Religious beliefs shape our thinking on cloning, stem. For some people, the discussion of ethical objections to cloning to producechildren could end here. The cloning of plants has been going on for centuries, and scientists began cloning experiments with small animals as early as the 1960s. Several consumeradvocate groups are working to encourage a tracking program that.
It seems clear to all of us, however, given the current stage of science in this area, that. Ethical issues raised by abortion and euthanasia are part of the subject matter of bioethics, which deals with the ethical dimensions of new developments in medicine and the biological sciences. For example, a child born from an adult dna cloning from his father would be, in effect, a delayed twin of one of his parents. The report begins with a fascinating history of cloning before moving on to the ethical issues raised by its applications, beginning with the use of cloning to create children. Religious groups are divided, with some opposing the technology as usurping. In order to clone animals, many attempts must be made before a viable clone is created.
Though genetically identical, cloned humans are technically due the same rights of any human. This is a procedure whose initial stages are identical to adult dna cloning. Cloning also involves the destruction of the human embryo. The ethics of animal research come into play, where many, such as the. Ethics and cloning british medical bulletin oxford. Chapter 26 ethical implications of cloning ronald m. Human cloning would still face ethical objections from a majority of. Indeed, the commission itself is unable to agree at this time on all the ethical issues that surround the issue of cloning human beings in this manner. As often happens when a powerful new scientific tool is. For example, it took hundreds of attempts to clone.
It will also set out recommendations to the legislature regarding regulation of human cloning. Sandel perspectives in biology and medicine the ethical implications of human cloning spring 2005 volume 48, number 2 michael j. But apart from religion, people feel that eugenic engineering is a bad thing. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. The ethical issues in animal cloning given the diverse motivations and types of animal cloning, the ethical terrain is complex. In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice and possibilities of cloning, especially human cloning. It is a production of a person, rather than a creation. Since 1997, when scottish scientists cloned a sheep, cloning has come to the forefront of the scientific and religious worlds. Ethical issuesdonation egg donor needed couple seeks egg donor with 1420 sat or 33 act, 1828 yrs old, 54510, attractive, athletic and healthy. Though animal and reproductive cloning are a concern for some religious sects, today the debate is mostly centered on the cloning of human embryonic stem cells, which are used for treatment and research of diseases. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading human cloning biomedical ethics. Digital cloning a scifi dream or a legal nightmare. Mainline protestant sects of christianity tend to have no particular objection to. Some even find ethical room for the cloning of humans.
With the recent advent of cloning, it seems we have ignored this and taken our technology forward to point where we forget about religion. Human cloning would still face ethical objections from a majority of concerned people, as well as opposition from diverse religions. Some of the fears and apprehensions are based on misconceptions of the science, but others are real and substantial. Therapeutic cloning is also called biomedical cloning, and research cloning. In this section, i wish to present some elements of the cultural context. Most muslim countries have not yet introduced laws on embryonic stem cell research and human cloning. Canadian fertility and anthology society, program supplement, 1993. While the bible does not specifically deal with the subject of human cloning, there are principles in scripture which may shed more light on the concept. Inherently interdisciplinary in scope, the field benefits from the contributions of professionals outside philosophy, including physicians, lawyers, scientists, and.
Panelists at the event, representing christianity, judaism, and islam, each briefly presented their faiths teachings about the. First, dna is removed from the nucleus of a creatures cell. To its credit, the report describes in a fairminded way the supposed benefits of cloningtoproducechildren. Many ethical and religious ideals have a conflict with the cloning pr. There is great public concern with the ethics of human cloning. Green he science of reproductive and therapeutic cloning has stirred heated ethical debates. What are the ethical dilemmas associated with human cloning. The national bioethics advisory commissions report to president clinton, cloning human beings, lists a number of objections raised by christian ethicists and moral theologians to the possible application of somatic cell nuclear transfer technologies to human cloning. Ethical issues of recombinant dna technology essay example. But in almost every case, the religious debate is still openended. From a religious standpoint, many argue that the act of cloning makes humans god, an equality not viewed as appropriate as humans lack omniscience. Religions reveal little consensus on cloning health. Human cloning breakthrough prompts religious objections.
Jeremy rifkin, president of the foundation on economic trends in washington dc, leads a coalition of 300 religious and ethics organizations from around the world. Picking a position on cloning is actually an exercise in revisiting basic religious beliefs, says coutney campbell, director of the program for ethics, science and the environment at oregon state university. Jul 28, 2018 covering an array of important topics. On the contrary, the nbac report spelt out many of the other ethical objections from both religious and secular sources, and stated its intention of setting the basis for a national discussion on. That is a question that has been asked quite often in recent times. The first and last question to ask is indeed why or why not, and keep on drilling down until you get something in objective reality. But the real religious controversy began when dolly the sheep was born on july 5,1997. There are many, many issues up for debate, one of the biggest issues is cloning goes against many peoples religious beliefs, which is a debate in itself, so now mentioned, well leave it there. Im executive director of the pew forum on religion and public life. To my mind, the most important of these is who isare going to be the legal parents of the cloned person. In doing so, i show that there is a common component between the religious objections and the secular objections to human cloning. The controversies remain, and new concerns have emerged, but cloning for therapeutic purposes will ultimately be accepted. People find that cloning is wrong because god did not intend for it to happen and what not. Other than opposition to the more sinister possibilities, such as the creation of spareparts humans, there is hardly consensus about the ethics of cloning.
In this case the only serious why nots i am aware of are religious objections god doesnt want us to and har. The low rate of cloning success may improve in the future. In the context of a rapidly burgeoning literature on the topic of cloning and related issues, this addition is welcome in bringing together these different approaches. The advocates for both sides of the issue have many reasons to clone or not to clone. Have the ethical questions surrounding cloning changed since. Several religious groups, including from protestant, catholic, jewish, muslim, hindu, and buddhist faiths, have rejected animal cloning on ethical grounds.
The legislature plans to take up this discussion after january. That has never happened before and may lead to emotional difficulties. Ever since the advent of cloning, there have been arguments for and against this process. The legal and ethical issues of cloning that make it. I am also assuming that you are referring to human reproductive cloning. Beyond issuing a general call for caution, the worlds. Dolly the sheep, the first cloned mammal, was born in 1996. Religious values and ethical values are not in opposition to each other. Ethical issues in animal cloning university of pennsylvania. Jan 20, 2008 bulletsome people have expressed concern about the effects that cloning would have on relationships. There are many religious views on cloning, and there is much debate over the many. Other cloning projects seek to create diseaseresistant animals, which could lead to healthier animal lives and greater animal welfare.
Some debaters argue in favor of human cloning for the purposes of. Sandel perspectives in biology and medicine footnote 1. Critics argue there are other ethical techniques for creating stem cells that may help cure illnesses like parkinsons disease and diabetes and that the alternatives do not require cloning human embryos or destroying them. A dialogue on state regulation was convened october 12, 2001, by the markkula center for applied ethics at santa clara university. There are other objections to cloning on moral grounds, such as the possibility of creating a superrace, the harvesting of humans for the purpose of parts for transplants, etc.
I am indebted to george annas for this hypothetical see annas 1989. Perspectives on human cloning are theoretical, as human therapeutic and reproductive cloning are not commercially used. Religious positions on human cloning are pluralistic in their premises. Asian religions worry less than western religions that biotechnology is.
There are a number of reasons why human cloning can violate ethics. These objections, summarized under three categories, are generally based on or related to the biblical claim that. Project muse human cloning from the viewpoint of islamic. Moral and legal issues concerning contemporary human. No unified religious perspective on human cloning exists. Bioethicists, policy makers, and the media have been quick to identify the key ethical issues involved in human reproductive cloning and to argue, almost unanimously, for an international ban on.
Cloning and genetic engineering are viewed by these groups as tantamount to playing god. We have asked our panelists to talk about the ethical and religious. The issue of human reproductive cloning has recently received a great deal attention in public discourse. In each of her monthly cycles, a woman usually produces only one or two mature eggs. Christians are still unmoved from their blanket opposition to all cloning. In summary,animal cloning raises two types of moral problems. Biological, ethical, and social considerations pnas. In a prescient 1982 contribution, british philosopher ruth chadwick listed the main objections to cloning, addressed and refuted them from a preference utilitarian point of view. Ethical issues in animal cloning 328 abstract the issue of human reproductive cloning has recently received a great deal attention in public discourse. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research. Rns news that scientists had for the first time recovered stem cells from cloned human embryos prompted dire warnings from religious leaders who say the research crosses a moral red line and could lead to designer babies. Sep 07, 2009 this article is a very brief overview of the stem cell debate from the point of view of muslims. Such clones are something one would imagine as software versions of peoples minds. But beyond the scientific level, the cloning issue has been controversial since ethics and morality on the same day when the idea was developed, there is this almost 100 years, and ethical questions raised about human cloning are several levels.
However, the stem cells are removed from the preembryo with the intent of producing tissue or a whole organ for transplant back into the person who supplied the dna. The advantages and disadvantages of human cloning raise moral, ethical, scientific and safety questions. Human cloning is a topic of worldwide controversy and ethical and religious debate. Religious perspectives on human biotechnologies vary widely, depending in part on the specific technology or application. The therapeutic cloning of organs debate is extremely similar to abortion and the issues surrounding the rights of the unborn child. Its purpose was to bring together experts from the fields of science, religion, ethics, and law to discuss how the state of california should proceed in regulating human cloning and stem cell. Many countries disallow reproductive cloning because of these questions, but some do allow research. Study 28 terms ethics chapter 18 study set flashcards.
This is very much a case of ignorance and prejudice on the part of influential politicians and religious zealots who have little or no knowledge of these sophisticated techniques and the inherent difficulties contained in development of viable clones to make. Representatives of three of the worlds major religions tangled over the beginnings of human life, the disposal of surplus embryos from in vitro fertilization clinics, and the conduct of embryonic stem cell research wednesday march 14 at harvard divinity school. Christian ethics and cloning is fast becoming a topic that is difficult to ignore. The ethical implications of human cloning spring 2005 volume 48, number 2 243 it might be replied that cloning and genetic engineering are in principle no different from other ways in which parents go to great lengths to produce children of a certain kind, or designer children. A serious issue in the area of cloning, as archbishop christodoulos points out, is the matter of playing god. Yet religious opposition to cloning may indeed be rooted in ignorance or hypocrisy. Some objections relate to safety of human cloning experiments, because the process is far from being. Not necessarily human cloning, but all sorts of artificial cloning. The process of being natural is all that matters, so that no body will be blamed of the outcome.
In south korea, when hwang woo suk reported creating human embryonic stem cells through cloning, he did not apologize for offending religious taboos. Ethical and religious issues 89 concerns about the safety of cloning, as fisc hbach and fischbach state, stem cells produced by therapeutic cloning have the advantage over those harvested from embryos resulting from ivf or aborted foetuses in that the cells generated through therapeutic cloning. Ethical and religious issues 89 concerns about the safety of cloning, as fisc hbach and fischbach state, stem cells produced by therapeutic cloning have the advantage over those harvested from embryos resulting from ivf or aborted foetuses in that the cells generated through therapeutic cloning are. While its true that by accident or neglect not all children are born into a supportive, loving home, its abundantly clear that its the. It basically goes against all of the religious beliefs. Human reproductive cloning remains universally condemned, primarily for the psychological, social, and physiological risks associated with cloning. There are plenty of arguments against cloning especially against cloning humans ranging from scientific issues, to the practicality of cloning, to religious objections. Hinduism views on cloning are very diverse and logical. A fundamental argument is that cloning is ethically wrong and various religious groups have rejected it saying that cloning is equivalent to playing god. What are the solutions to the ethical problems posed by human. Critics argue there are other ethical techniques for creating stem cells that may help cure illnesses like parkinsons disease and.
Religions reveal little consensus on cloning health special. On the scientific side, we see that a large percentage of cloning efforts end in failure. Chapter three religious perspectives over the last twentyfive years religious thinkers have discussed the prospect of human cloning in the context of longstanding religious traditions that often influence and guide citizens responses to new technologies. In light of the risks and other ethical concerns raised by this form of human experimentation, we therefore conclude that cloning to producechildren should not be attempted. Religiously based objections to human cloning springerlink. This is an attempt to explore the pros and cons of human cloning and to provide enough information of both sides of the arguments in order for the reader to make their own informed decision on whether human cloning is ethical or not. For an overview of the evaluation of cloning by the main religious groups see, for example, coleturner 1997 and walters 2004. Compared to therapeutic cloning and its medicinal benefits, there are only a few situations in which reproductive human cloning seems ethical or moral.
Ethical issues in assisted reproductive technologies. Most religious leaders are in step with public sentiment in opposing human inheritable genetic modification and reproductive cloning, and recognize social and ethical as well as theological objections to them. Christians take multiple positions in the debate on the morality of human cloning. In the case of the former, it will meet strong opposition. Youll be glad to hear its a tightly regulated area in the cloning sector. Jun 26, 2015 ill try and examine each possible ethical concern that i can think of since you havent listed any, ill assume you mean any across the spectrum.
I have a problem with that because religious ethics is very much integral to the religion itself. Ethical, social, and religious values will come into play when seeking to decide. In bioethics, the ethics of cloning refers to a variety of ethical positions regarding the practice. For the past five years, the prospect of human cloning has been the subject of considerable public attention and sharp moral debate, both in the united states and around the. Other faiths have found room in their traditions for therapeutic cloningthe use of cloned cells for research and health reasons, but not for breeding humans. Also, many religious groups could not use products from specific organisms, e. Cloning is a dominant topic under the broader category of biotechnology. Religious beliefs shape our thinking on cloning, stem cells and gene editing. Christian response to human cloning tennessee research and. The report will discuss the science of cloning, and the ethical and legal considerations of applications of cloning technology. Ethical and theological objections to animal cloning. The catholic church, in particular, has voiced strong opposition against cloning.
Each day it seems there is more news from the scientific world of another milestone reached in cloning technology. Project muse the ethical implications of human cloning. However, a confused population looking for clear ethical wisdom on cloning might be. Here is a discussion about the ethical issues that have arisen concerned with cloning humans. The complete program and video recordings of most presentations are. Im doing alevel biology and i have to know some things about cloning, i know about reproductive and therapeutic cloning but i also need to know some of the ethical issues around the problem. An introduction to biblical moral reasoning is to help readers apply a biblical worldview to difficult ethical issues, including wealth and poverty, marriage and divorce, birth control, abortion, euthanasia, homosexuality, business practices, environmental stewardship, telling the truth, knowing gods. Lastly, from ethical and religious standpoints, the question of immortality will. Of course, human cloning technology engages not only religious, cultural, social, and moral challenges, but also ethical and legal issues, as well as human and fundamental rights concerns. The ethical implications of human cloning spring 2005 volume 48, number 2 michael j. It involves the process of somatic cell nuclear transfer in which the nucleus of a cell from a human patients body is injected into a human ovum which has had its nucleus removed the goal of therapeutic cloning is to. While many of these views are religious in origin, some of the questions raised by cloning are faced by secular perspectives as well.
1026 432 489 180 1371 459 40 1467 128 573 4 883 376 372 326 1284 278 473 368 1527 526 1059 819 1579 369 825 615 883 693 62 896 1447 567 963 612 582 509 1165 344 924 187